A former food delivery worker jailed under Hong Kong’s national security law for chanting independence slogans at protests merely spouted “empty words” without intending to advocate the city’s secession from mainland China, his legal counsel has argued.
The Court of Appeal on Tuesday heard the first-ever application stemming from the legislation imposed by Beijing in June 2020, with defence lawyers alleging the sentencing judge had made multiple errors when assessing their client’s culpability.
A judge hand-picked by the city’s leader to oversee national security proceedings sentenced Adam Ma Chun-man to 69 months in jail last November for inciting secession on 20 occasions during a three-month span, which occurred soon after the new law took effect.
Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answers with SCMP Knowledge, our new platform of curated content with explainers, FAQs, analyses and infographics brought to you by our award-winning team.
Popularly known as a “second-generation Captain America” for his dressing up as the superhero during previous demonstrations, Ma had used slogans such as “Hong Kong independence, the only way out”, “Hongkongers, build our country” and “Liberate Hong Kong; revolution of our times” – a signature rallying call of the 2019 anti-government protests.
The former food delivery worker had also promoted his political ideals on social media platforms and during interviews with news outlets, where he called on other residents to advocate independence in schools and prepare for the next “revolution”.
District Court Judge Stanley Chan Kwong-chi found the offence committed by Ma to be of a serious nature, which warranted a jail term of five to 10 years based on the national security law’s sentencing regime.
On Tuesday, senior counsel Edwin Choy Wai-bond, who represents the appellant, described Ma’s past conduct as being similar to speaking in an echo chamber and could not have objectively undermined national unity.
The barrister also argued that several expressions repeated by Ma were devoid of substance and should not be cited as evidence of his support for violence.
“The defendant lacked detailed planning. What he called ‘build our country’ or ‘build our army’ were but empty words,” Choy said.
“He was just one of many people who took part in the so-called ‘Sing with You’ protests, shouting slogans and calling others out … Few people had echoed him.”
Choy contended that Chan had erred in increasing Ma’s sentence by pointing to his lack of remorse and “irrelevant matters”, such as his subjective opinion that the former food delivery worker’s offence was an act of self-gratification to validate his existence.
He submitted that the case was of a minor nature, whereby a sentence alternative to jail would be applicable, but acknowledged that five years imprisonment would be an appropriate penalty for his client.
Giving his preliminary observations, Chief Justice of the High Court Jeremy Poon Shiu-chor said the lower court appeared to have their reasons for increasing Ma’s sentence to reflect his chance of reoffending, especially when he had repeatedly breached the law within a short period of time.
Justices Derek Pang Wai-cheong and Anthea Pang Po-kam also rejected the defence’s argument that Ma had misunderstood the effect of the new law, citing his mitigation letter to the lower court whereby he claimed he felt no shame or “the least bit of remorse”.
The bench will hand down its judgment on September 5.
The national security law outlaws acts of secession, subversion, terrorism and collusion with foreign forces, with a maximum sentence of life imprisonment applicable in serious cases.
More from South China Morning Post:
Hong Kong police chief warns viewers to avoid documentary about city’s social unrest over concerns of possible national security violations
Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam defends police action to close off Victoria Park on June 4, saying anniversary of Tiananmen Square crackdown could spur violent activism
This article Hong Kong’s self-styled ‘Captain America’ spouted ‘empty words’, legal counsel says in first appeal related to city’s national security law first appeared on South China Morning Post
For the latest news from the South China Morning Post download our mobile app. Copyright 2022.
A smile and a wave must be good enough for Southeast Asian fans when EPL teams like Liverpool visit the region to fulfil their commercial responsibilities, says Neil Humphreys.
As more top seeds fell by the wayside, Loh Kean Yew has made serene progress into the Singapore Badminton Open men's singles quarter-finals.
Paris's traditional Bastille Day military parade on Thursday is a salute to Ukraine, and to France's eastern European allies who are among guests of honour, officials said.
Indian shares clinged on to early gains on Friday, supported by gains in consumer goods companies, but the benchmark indexes were headed for their first weekly loss in four on fears over aggressive rate hikes by central banks. The NSE Nifty 50 index was up 0.3% at 15,985.20, as of 0509 GMT, while the S&P BSE Sensex rose 0.24% to 53,543.73. Both the indexes are down more than 1% this week and on track for their first weekly loss in four.
A man was shot dead in British Columbia on Thursday who local media reports said was Ripudaman Singh Malik, a Canadian Sikh businessman acquitted in connection with the 1985 Air India bombing that killed 329 people. The Royal Canadian Mounted Police's (RCMP) statement did not name the man but said he died on the scene in Surrey, British Columbia. An RCMP spokesperson said they could not name the victim and that the investigation was ongoing.
Africa's fastest man Ferdinand Omanyala told AFP on Thursday he has given up on competing at the World Athletics Championships in the United States because of a delay in getting a visa.
Morocco's King Mohammed VI has authorised a reorganisation of the country's Jewish community, a "component" of national culture in the North African country, according to the royal palace.
Group of 20 finance ministers and central bank chiefs from top economies met in Indonesia Friday for talks on the fallout from Russia's invasion of Ukraine, with the host warning them failure to tackle energy and food crises would be catastrophic.
A baby elephant was dramatically rescued from a manhole in central Thailand after his mother was sedated to allow the operation to proceed, wildlife officials said.
Italy's teetering government was thrown a lifeline Thursday after the country's president refused to accept the resignation of Prime Minister Mario Draghi, insisting he address parliament in a bid to avoid snap elections.
Dimuth Karunaratne's Sri Lanka will be looking to build on their winning momentum at Galle as the hosts take on Pakistan in a likely spin battle in the opening Test starting Saturday.
Ian Foster has downplayed the pressure mounting on him as New Zealand coach, saying on Thursday that all his focus is on beating an outstanding Ireland in the series-deciding third Test.
Russian missiles struck Vinnytsia in central Ukraine Thursday, killing at least 23 people including three children, in what President Volodymyr Zelensky called "an open act of terrorism".
A seven-month ban on Twitter use in Nigeria was unlawful, according to a court ruling by West Africa's regional bloc ECOWAS seen by AFP on Thursday.
Lizzo's summer turned up a notch Friday, with the poster child of self-love dropping her long-awaited album "Special" fresh off an Emmy nomination and ahead of a forthcoming tour.
Cupping his hands to his ears, one of the contestants in an annual competition for Turkey's most melodious religious voice leans closer to the microphone to intone a tender call to prayer.
The United Kingdom said Friday the Kremlin was "fully responsible" for the death of a British captive in east Ukraine as rescue workers in Vinnytsia scoured debris for missing people after devastating Russian rocket attacks.
Southwest Europe baked under sweltering temperatures on Friday for a fifth day, with the heat sparking devastating wildfires, forcing the evacuations of thousands and ruining holidays.
US President Joe Biden said Friday he had confronted Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman over attacks on dissidents during his visit to Saudi Arabia, a country he once vowed to make a "pariah" over its human rights abuses.
The United Nations Security Council agreed Friday to ask member states to ban the transfer of small arms to Haiti, rocked by deadly gang violence, but stopped short of a full embargo requested by China.